Pearl of Wisdom

?O 'Ali, four things are truly back-breaking: a leader who disobeys Allah whilst his command is obeyed ...'

Prophet Muhammad al-Mustafa [sawa]
al-Khisal, p. 206, no. 24

Latest Answers

Sexual Ethics & Morals
# 824 - looking for someone in edda mu
Salaat / Prayers
# 709 - Passing wind from the rear
Business / Investment
# 808 - Masjid or Imam Bargah
Sexual Ethics & Morals
# 807 - penetration during period
# 806 - Female masturbation
Divorce / Talaq
# 798 - Divorce
Miscellaneous
# 797 - Kiss
# 792 - hidden buried treasure
Interfaith Dialogue
# 781 - Jesus death
Fasting / Sawm / Roza
# 776 - Husbands permissn

Receive Qul Updates

Name:
Email:
Ask Qul - QA
Question : #204 Category: Shia Sunni Dialogue
Subject: misc enquiry
Question: Assalamuiliekum Wa rohmatolahi wa barkartu,

May peace and blessings be upon you always.

Hello my name is Faruq. I am a Muslim revert from Australia who now lives in Indonesia with my wife.

I have some questions about Shia Islam that I hope you can answer for me.

So far I have been following Islam mainly according to the Maliki school of fiqh. Which although uncommon I feel Imam Maliks rulings make the most sense for me.

I have however always believed in the complete unification of this Ummah because from what I have read it is what the prophet Muhammad wanted from us, to be unified. Thus I have always kept communication open to all Islamic groups and mixed freely with them all, including Shia.

Now in Indonesia I have no Shia friends like I used to have in Australia. There are some questions though that have resurfaced for me recently through listening to some of Prof. Hussanain's lectures on Tauweed.

1. Shia follow 12 imams after the Prophet and the Sahaabat. Do these imams introduce new aspects to Islam or new Dalal outside what we received from the first generation of Muslims who accepted the original message? Or can they be compared to the four Imams of the major mazhabs in Islam?

2. Do all Shia practice self mutilation? Is this a practice from the 12 Imams or because of cultural spiritualisim (like sufisim)?

3. Is there disagreement amongst Shia scholars on the permissibility of Muta'ah/Temporary Marriage?

I hope you can answer my questions and my sincere hope is that my questions can bring me closer to my Shia brothers in Islam for Allah has made us all brothers in faith and we should honour this always.

Wassalamuiliekum wa rohmatolahi wa barakartu,
Answer: Salamu Alaykum


1) The Ithna-Ashari or 12 Imams follow the prophet and after him the 12 leaders of Islam chosen by God al-mighty. They respect the chosen Sahabah and according to the fatwa of Ayatollah Khamenei and other Maraja it is haram to insult the Sahabah of the prophets and the wives of the prophet. The Islam which the 12 Imams preach is the same Islam that the Prophet (p.b.u.h) preached, which is there is no god but Allah and Muhammad is the last messenger of Allah and the same fiqh the prophet taught. The 4 Imams can not be compared to the 12 Imams due to the fact that the Shias believe the 12 Imams were chosen by God and they had infallibility.

2)Self-Mutilation is Haram in Islam, so neither the Shia practices this nor the Imams.

3)There is no disagreement amongst the Shia Scholars on the permissibility of Mutah, All scholars consider Mutah to be halal within the condtions and an Islamic Marriage.

With Prayers
Wasalam

If you require further clarification on this answer, please use the feature to respond to the stated answer.
Copyright © 2018 Qul. All Rights Reserved.
Developed by B19 Design.